When children experience emotional upheaval, such as returning home upset after a challenging day at school, the way we, as parents, respond can significantly influence the outcome of the situation. Missteps in these conversations can deepen the child's distress, while the right approach can provide comfort and solutions. Let's explore how different responses can affect these delicate moments and discover the most effective way to communicate during an emotional high.
Scenario 1: Misplaced Rationalisation
Imagine a child comes home, visibly upset, and the interaction unfolds as follows:
Child: Comes home, drops school bag, slumps onto the couch.
Dad: “Why the long face? You look like you lost your best friend.”
Child: “I had a really bad day at school. Nothing went right.
”Dad: “Oh come on, it can’t be that bad. Everyone has bad days. It’s not the end of the world.
”Child: “But Dad, I got a bad mark on my maths test, and my friends were all ignoring me.
”Dad: “Well, maybe you should study harder next time. And friends come and go. Don’t let it bother you.”
Child: “But I studied really hard for that test, and it still went wrong. And I don’t understand why my friends were being mean.”
Dad: “Life isn’t always fair. You’ll get over it. Now, go do your homework.”
Child: “I just wanted to talk about it. I feel really alone.”
Dad: “You’re not alone. You’ve got family. Now, let’s not make a mountain out of a molehill. Off you go.”
Can you see what goes wrong here? The father attempts to rationalise the situation and minimise the child's feelings. Although the father means well, his approach results in the child feeling misunderstood and even more alone.
Scenario 2: Attempted Rationalisation with Good Intentions
In another attempt, the conversation might go slightly differently but still misses the emotional mark:
Dad: “Hey there, buddy. You look like you’ve had a tough day. Want to talk about it?”
Child: “I had a really bad day at school. Nothing went right.”
Dad: “Well, you know, sometimes we create our own reality with our thoughts. Have you tried thinking more positively?”
Child: “I got a bad grade on my maths test, and my friends were all ignoring me.”
Dad: “You should study a bit more for your tests. Maybe a new study method would help. Have you tried mindfulness meditation to reduce your stress?”
Child: “But I studied really hard for that test, and it still went wrong. And I don’t understand why my friends were being mean.”
Dad: “Sometimes people project their own insecurities onto others. Maybe your friends are just dealing with their own issues. Have you thought about talking to them about how you feel?”
Child: “But I felt really alone today.”
Dad: “Loneliness is often a state of mind. You should try to reframe your thoughts. You’re not alone, you just haven’t found the right connection yet.”
Despite the father's attempts to provide strategies and a positive spin, the child still feels a lack of emotional validation and support.
Scenario 3: Effective Emotional Validation and Support
Let's consider a more effective approach that illustrates proper emotional validation and support:
Dad: “Hey there, buddy. You look like you’ve had a tough day. Want to talk about it?”
Child: “I had a really bad day at school. Nothing went right.”
Dad: “I’m sorry to hear that. Do you want to tell me what happened?”
Child: “I got a bad mark on my maths test, and my friends were all ignoring me.”
Dad: “That sounds really tough. It must have been hard to deal with both things at once. How did that make you feel?”
Child: “I felt really stupid about the test, and I don’t know why my friends were being mean. I felt so alone.”
Dad: “It’s completely okay to feel upset about those things. You worked hard for that test, and it’s frustrating when the result isn’t what you hoped for. And feeling left out by friends can really hurt.”
Child: “Yeah, it was really awful.”
Dad: “Let’s take this one step at a time. How about we review the maths test together? Maybe we can figure out what went wrong and talk to your teacher if needed. As for your friends, sometimes people act out for reasons that have nothing to do with us. Would you like some help thinking of ways to talk to them?”
Child: “I’d like that. Thanks, Dad.”
Dad: “Anytime, buddy. Remember, you’re not alone. We’ll get through this together.”
Child: “I feel a bit better now. I’m glad we talked.”
Dad: “Me too. Let’s tackle that maths test first, and we can think about your friends afterwards. One step at a time.”
Child: Smiling, “Okay, Dad. Thanks.”
By first validating the child’s feelings and then gently exploring the issues, the father creates a space for emotional healing and practical problem-solving. This approach fosters a supportive dialogue, helping the child feel understood and less alone.
Conclusion
The key takeaway for parents is that during emotional outbursts or distress, children are often unable to process rational thought. They need their feelings acknowledged and validated first. Once they feel understood, they are more open to discussing solutions or accepting advice. By adopting a more empathetic and supportive approach, parents can help their children navigate their emotions more effectively, leading to better outcomes for both the child and the parent-child relationship.
Are you a parent (or teacher) of a creative child with challenging behaviours? Would you like new, effective insights and strategies that create harmony in the home, empowering your child to make more productive choices?
Join our brand new evening class, coming up in January:
Comments